Showing posts with label War. Show all posts
Showing posts with label War. Show all posts

Tuesday, January 2, 2007

BUSH LEAGUE WAR TOPS 3000 U.S. DEAD


The American 'crusade' into Iraq has proven to be a disaster from the outset to its inevitable end-game which will be a bit like --no, a LOT like - the ignominious exit from Saigon of U.S. troops thiry years ago. The war on terrorism, or, rather, the war on Islamist fanaticism, the clash of civilizations is quite real, and Iraq has added to the enemy's credit, not ours. The *one* thing we might salvage of honor is to help the one non-Arab legitimate national group seeking its own place in the sunlight, the long-suffering Kurdish people. If we ultimately do not abandon our friends and genuine allies the Kurds of "northern Iraq" (see banner below), and simply leave the Iraqis to the barbaric Islamist Civil War they so richly deserve, but *leave*, we will have done well, served American interests well, and done a bit to make up for the farce the Bush administration has foisted upon the American people and military in the shadow of 9/11.
northern iraq


THE SOUND OF DISTANT THUNDER-LAST WORDS ON THE SUBJECT

"They sow the wind
and reap the whirlwind. "
Hosea 8:7

""The Baath party and Baathists still exist in Iraq, and nobody can marginalize it."
Samir al-Obaidi, who attended a Saddam memorial


BITS FROM THE MEDIA - THE DAY AFTER THE LYNCHING OF THE PREVIOUS (SECULAR) DICTATOR BY THE CURRENT ISLAMIST DICTATORSHIP

Report: U.S. Tried To Delay Saddam Hanging
BAGHDAD, Jan. 1, 2007(CBS/AP) In the hours before Saddam Hussein was led to the gallows by men in ski masks, the U.S. ambassador to Iraq reportedly tried, but failed, to delay the execution, reports CBS News correspondent Randall Pinkston.

A Reuters report, quoting Iraqi officials familiar with the discussions, says ambassador Zalmay Khalilzad insisted that Prime Minister Nuri al-Maliki provide certain documents, including a signature from Iraq's president.

Iraq's national security adviser Mowaffak al-Rubaie confirmed to CBS News that the U.S. "brought to the attention of the government of Iraq to be careful with ... documentation" and that Iraq provided the required paperwork including "a consent document from President Jalal Talabani."

The U.S. had leverage. From the moment of his capture, to his trial and sentencing, Saddam was in U.S. military custody, reports Pinkston. After the flurry of negotiations, Saddam wasn't handed over until a few hours before his execution.

After Hussein's burial today, rage over the hanging spilled into the streets in many parts of the Sunni Muslim hartland Monday, especially in Samarra where a mob of angry protesters broke the locks off the badly damaged Shiite Golden Dome mosque and marched through carrying a mock coffin and photo of the executed former leader.

Sunni extremists had blown apart the glistening dome on the Shiite holy place 10 months earlier, setting in motion the sectarian slaughter that now grips the troubled land.

The U.S. death toll climbed to at least 3,002 by the final day of 2006 as the American military reported the deaths of two more soldiers in an explosion Sunday in Diyala Province, northeast of the capital.

The Samarra protest was particularly significant because it signaled a widening expression of defiance among Sunnis, the minority Muslim sect in Iraq that had enjoyed special status and power under Saddam and had oppressed the now-ascendant Shiite majority for centuries.

Until Saddam was executed, excluding a few days of protests after his death sentence was handed down Nov. 5, the broader Sunni population had sought a low profile in the sectarian conflict that had seen thousands of them killed or driven from their homes by Shiite militia forces since the Samarra bombing Feb. 22.

Sunni insurgents and foreign fighters of al-Qaida in Iraq had been conducting a bloody insurgency with attacks on U.S. forces and brutal bombings against Shiite civilians since the summer of 2003, shortly after Saddam was ousted in the American-led invasion.

While many Sunnis were known to be sympathetic to the insurgency, its active membership had not reached broadly into the Sunni population. The angry Sunni protests that now are building in the country could presage deeper involvement by what until now had been a largely quiescent group.

The Sunnis were not only angered by Saddam's hurried execution, just four days after an appeals court upheld his conviction and sentence, but were increasingly incensed by the unruly and undignified manner in which the hanging was carried out.

A clandestine video of the hanging showed Saddam was taunted by some present at the execution with chants of "Muqtada, Muqtada, Muqtada" in the last moments of his life. The chants were a reference to anti-American Shiite cleric Muqtada al-Sadr, who runs one of the deadliest religious militias in Iraq and is a major power behind the government of al-Maliki, who had pushed for Saddam to be hanged before the year was out.

Saddam was put to death on the eve of the Shiite celebration of the Eid al-Ahda, the major Muslim festival marking the end of the hajj pilgrimage to Mecca and a remembrance Abraham's willingness to sacrifice of his son, now symbolized by the slaughtering of sheep.

The first judge in the so-called Dujail trial, Rizgar Mohammed Amin, said Saddam's execution in the during the eid was illegal according to Iraqi law. Sunni Muslim festivities marking the holiday began on the same day that Saddam was hanged. Rizgar, a Kurd, was removed as chief judge in the case after Shiite complaints that he was too lenient. He was replaced in January 2006 by Raouf Rasheed Abdel-Rahman.

"The implementation of Saddam's execution during Eid al-adha is illegal according to chapter 9 of the tribunal law. Article 27 states that nobody, even the president (Jalal Talabani), may change rulings by the tribunal and the implementation of the sentence should not happen until 30 days after publication that the appeals court has upheld the tribunal verdict.

The hanging during the Eid al-Adha period (also) contradicts Iraqi and Islamic custom. "Article 290 of the criminal code of 1971 (which was largely used in the Saddam trial) states that no verdict should implemented during the official holidays or religious festivals," he said.

In northern Baghdad, hundreds of Sunnis conducted a demonstration to mourn Saddam in a predominantly Sunni neighborhood.

"The Baath party and Baathists still exist in Iraq, and nobody can marginalize it," said Samir al-Obaidi, 48, who attended a Saddam memorial in the Azamiyah neighborhood.

In Dor, 77 miles north of Baghdad, hundreds more took to the streets to inaugurate a giant mosaic of Saddam.

Children carried toy guns and men fired into the air. Mourners at a mosque in Saddam's hometown of Tikrit slaughtered sheep as a sacrifice for their former leader. The mosque's walls were lined with condolence cards from tribes in southern Iraq and Jordan who were unable to travel to the memorial.

Saddam's eldest daughter briefly attended a protest Monday in Amman - her first public appearance since her father was hanged.

Raghad Saddam Hussein stopped in at the demonstration staged by the Professional Associations, a body that groups unions for doctors, engineers and lawyers, in its office parking lot in west Amman.

"God bless you, and I thank you for honoring Saddam, the martyr," two witnesses recalled Raghad Saddam Hussein as telling the protesters, who included a junior Cabinet minister, on her arrival. She left a minute later.

Also, U.S. forces killed six people in a raid on the Baghdad offices of a top Sunni politician, Saleh al-Mutlaq, on suspicion it was being used as an al-Qaida safe house, the military and Iraqi police said.

The U.S. military said took on heavy fire from automatic weapons and rocket-propelled grenades as they sought to enter the building. Al-Mutlaq is a senior member of the National Dialogue Front, which holds 11 of the 275 seats in Iraq's parliament.

Police said the raid also took place near the home of Salama al-Khafaji, a former Shiite parliamentarian who abandoned her residence after escaping an assassination attempt last year.

Ground troops were backed by helicopters that "engaged the enemy with precision point target machine gun fire," the military said. It was unclear whether the deaths resulted from the ground assault or fire from U.S. helicopters.

Associated Press Television News footage showed masses of rubble in the area and what appeared to be a long smear of blood where a body had been dragged across the floor of one of the buildings.

Walls in the buildings were pitted with what looked to be the impact of bullets and shrapnel.

With the announced deaths of two more soldiers, the Associated Press count of fatalities showed at least 113 U.S. service members died in December, the bloodiest month of 2006, a year in which at least 822 forces died.

Police reported finding the bodies of 40 handcuffed, blindfolded and bullet-riddled bodies in Baghdad on the first day of the New Year. A police official, who refused to be named out of security fears, said "15 of these bodies found in one place," the largely industrial Sheik Omar district in northern Baghdad.

Otherwise the there were no reported violent deaths in the country Monday with the exception of the shooting death of an Iraqi worker for Algerian Embassy in Baghdad.

Also Monday, the Iraqi government sealed the offices of a privately owned television station, charging it had incited violence and hatred in its programming.

A journalist for Al-Sharqiya station, which broadcasts from Dubai, said the station closed its Baghdad office three months ago because of attacks on its staff.

"The channel administration decided to close it for security reasons," said the journalist, who spoke on condition of anonymity because of safety concerns.

Al-Sharqiya remained on the air late Monday. The station is owned by Saad al-Bazzaz, a one-time chief of radio and television for Saddam.

© MMVII The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Sunni anger over Saddam hanging spills into streets
Updated 1/1/2007 7:03 PM ET
BAGHDAD (AP) — Enraged crowds protested the hanging of Saddam Hussein across Iraq's Sunni heartland Monday, as a mob in Samara broke the locks off a bomb-damaged Shiite shrine and marched through carrying a mock coffin and photo of the dictator.

The demonstration in the Golden Dome, shattered in a bombing by Sunni extremists 10 months ago, suggests that many Sunni Arabs may now more actively support the small number of Sunni militants fighting the country's Shiite-dominated government. The Feb. 22 bombing of the shrine triggered the current cycle of retaliatory attacks between Sunnis and Shiia, in the form of daily bombings, kidnappings and murders.

Monday's protest came on a day that saw the U.S. military kill six Iraqis during a raid on the offices of a prominent Sunni political figure, who was suspected of giving al-Qaeda in Iraq fighters sanctuary.

Until Saddam's execution Saturday, most Sunnis sympathized with militants but avoided taking a direct role in the sectarian conflict — despite attacks by Shiite militia that have killed thousands of Sunnis or driven them from their homes. The current Sunni protests, which appear to be building, could signal a spreading militancy.

Sunnis were not only outraged by Saddam's hurried execution, just four days after an appeals court upheld his conviction and sentence. Many were also incensed by the unruly scene in the execution chamber, captured on video, in which Saddam was taunted with chants of "Muqtada, Muqtada, Muqtada."

The chants referred to Muqtada al-Sadr, a firebrand Shiite cleric who runs one of Iraq's most violent religious militias. He is a major power behind the government of Shiite Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki.

Many Sunnis are also upset that Saddam was put to death the day that Sunni celebrations began for Eid al-Ahda, a major Muslim festival. The judge who first presided over the case that resulted in Saddam's death sentence said the former dictator's execution at the start of Eid was illegal according to Iraqi law, and contradicted Islamic custom.

The law states that "no verdict should implemented during the official holidays or religious festivals," said Judge Rizgar Mohammed Amin, a Kurd.

Rizgar presided over Saddam's trial on charges he killed 148 Shiite men and boys in Dujail, north of Baghdad, in a botched assassination attempt in 1982. The judge was removed from the case after Shiite complaints that he was too lenient.

In a Sunni neighborhood in northern Baghdad, hundreds of demonstrators mourned the executed leader. Some praised the Baath Party, the outlawed nationalist group that under Saddam cemented Sunni Arab dominance of Iraq.

"The Baath party and Baathists still exist in Iraq, and nobody can marginalize it," said Samir al-Obaidi, 48, who attended a Saddam memorial in the Azamiyah neighborhood.

In Dor, 77 miles north of Baghdad, hundreds more took to the streets to attend the dedication of a giant mosaic of Saddam. Children carried toy guns and men fired real weapons into the air.

Mourners at a mosque in Saddam's hometown of Tikrit slaughtered sheep as a sacrifice for their former leader. The mosque's walls were lined with condolence cards from tribes in southern Iraq and Jordan who were unable to travel to the memorial.

Saddam's eldest daughter briefly attended a protest Monday in Jordan — her first public appearance since her father was hanged.

"God bless you, and I thank you for honoring Saddam, the martyr," said Raghad Saddam Hussein, according to two witnesses. She addressed members of the Professional Associations — an umbrella group of unions representing doctors, engineers and lawyers — in the group's office parking lot in west Amman.

In the midst of the protests, U.S. forces continued operations in Iraq.

Six Iraqis were killed in a U.S.-led raid on the Baghdad offices of a top Sunni politician, Saleh al-Mutlaq. The U.S. military and Iraqi police said they suspected the offices were being used as an al-Qaeda safe house.

Al-Mutlaq is a senior member of the National Dialogue Front, which holds 11 of the 275 seats in Iraq's parliament.

U.S. forces said they took on heavy fire from automatic weapons and rocket-propelled grenades as they sought to enter the building. Ground troops were backed by helicopters that "engaged the enemy with precision point target machine gun fire," the military said.

It was unclear whether the deaths resulted from the ground assault or fire from U.S. helicopters.

Associated Press Television News footage showed masses of rubble in the area and what appeared to be a long smear of blood where a body had been dragged across the floor of one of the buildings.

Walls were pitted with what appeared to be bullet and shrapnel holes.

The U.S. death toll, meanwhile, climbed to at least 3,002 by the final day of 2006 as the American military reported the deaths of two more soldiers in an explosion Sunday in Diyala Province, northeast of the capital. With the announcement, the Associated Press count of fatalities showed that at least 113 U.S. service members died in December. That makes it bloodiest month of 2006.

Police reported finding the bodies of 40 handcuffed, blindfolded and bullet-riddled bodies in Baghdad on the first day of the New Year. A police official, who refused to be named out of security fears, said 15 of the bodies were discovered in the mainly industrial Sheik Omar district of northern Baghdad.

An Iraqi worker for the Algerian Embassy in Baghdad was shot to death, police said.

Also Monday, the Iraqi government raided and sealed the offices of a privately owned television station, charging it had incited violence and hatred in its programming. In its coverage of the execution of Saddam over the weekend, a newscaster had worn black mourning clothes.

The satellite television channel Al-Sharqiya, which broadcasts from Dubai, remained on the air late Monday. The station is owned by Saad al-Bazzaz, a one-time chief of radio and television for Saddam.
Copyright 2006 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.



Find this article at:
http://www.usatoday.com/news/world/iraq/2007-01-01-saddam-protests_x.htm?csp=34

AMERICAN BLOOD ON BUSH'S HANDS

To mark or mourn this grim milestone, here is an E&P summary, based on official sources and the Iraq Coaliton Casualty Count web site, of the death tally so far.
*

Deaths by hostile fire: 2422 80.9%
Non-hostile: 578

Age 18-20: 517 17.2%
Age 21-30: 1813 60.9%

U.S. deaths since Bush said "Bring them on": 2,793
Coalition deaths since first January 2005 Iraqi election: 1,653

Days since invasion: 1,382
Average U.S. deaths per day: 2.36
Average last three months: 3.24

Death by IED attack: 1086 36%

Women killed: 62

White: 74%
Hispanic: 11%
Black: 10%

U.S. Army: 1549 51.9%
U.S. Marine: 755
National Guard and Reserves: 596

U.K. deaths: 127
From other countries: 123

Total wounded: over 22,000
Wounded this year: over 5,600

Estimate of Iraqi deaths since killing of Zarqawi in June 2006: 13,588

Total Iraqi deaths since invasion: 100,000 to 600,000.

U.S. deaths by state:

California 305 10.2%
Texas 266
Pennsylvania 144
New York 139
Ohio 130
Florida 125
Michigan 118

E&P Staff

Monday, January 1, 2007

SLIGHT UPDATE ON PREVIOUS ENTRY

Before 2006 ended:

Associated Press
U.S. Military Deaths in Iraq Hit 3,000
By The Associated Press 12.31.06, 7:46 PM ET


Do we really want to be in a country of Islamist Fanatics we only enable by being there?


Kurds, who are not Arabs, want their own country, are pro-western and moderate. We are welcome there.

In Iraq, we get nothing but what we paid for - a new, powerful trans-Iranian (i.e. Persian) Islamist Theocratic Empire that threatens now to stretch, under Bush administration policies, from Lebanon on the Mediterranian Sea to the borders of the Indian SubContinent.

Sunday, December 31, 2006

HOW NOT TO FIGHT TERRORISM







KILLING DICTATORS SELECTIVELY _ PART 276

THE SCORECARD

U.S. IRAQ CASUALTIES THROUGH 2006

KILLED TOTAL 2,999 (As of 12/31/06)




Let's get real, apart for the barbarity and crudity of killing a man subdued

by the state and powerless is cowardly, and most civilized nations except the

good ole USA has rejected it long since. The "crimes against humanity" argument

has been debated since Nuremberg...can a person be a criminal at a time when

they are not breaking the existing law of the land? Immoral, to be sure. If

combatants, subject to the rules of war. If non-combatant, perhaps not. There

were people of conscience - Robert Taft, one of JFK's "Profiles in Courage", was

an objector. People of good will can agree, but if we had to go into Iraq (we

did not), we should have done so quickly, snatched the wretched creature in

charge and shipped him off to Gitmo, or, better, the Hague, or even to the cell

next to General Noriega, I do not object to well-treated, tours of former

dictators. But I take no joy in their deaths once disarmed and degraded.

But the way this execution was carried out is loathsome and barbaric. I must

say Saddam, no worse than our 'allies' in Saudi or Uzbekistan or even Egypt,

really, was a lynching. It was a rush job--the victim was the old person on

camera not hooded (he refused, and he was shouted at by his 'executioners' and -

to his credit, more or less his last words were "Is this how Arabs act?" I

guess so--a few called for silence and dignity, the rest shouted abuse - a lynch

mob, and when they had killed him, danced on his corpse like savages. If this

is the "civilization we are are bringing to the Arab World, I don't think even

Texas executions would tolerate this kind of indignity, all duly recorded on

video. 3000 American G.I.s died for a 'country' that does this kind of barbaric

shit? 12,000 Maimed? For the Shi'ite fanatic Islamic Republic of Iraq? What

trash. Bush should be impeached. And we all should watch the tape, and feel

just a little ill.

I detest him - praising "Palestine" to the end, but I don't degrade, dehumanize

and then kill unarmed prisoners no matter what they SAY. In fact, defiant to

the end, he was almost -heroic. I hated the guy. I hated his regime. But I

wouldn't have treated Eichmann this way, which, by the way, he wasn't. Jews are

*not* savages, which maybe is the point.

GRAPH OF OPINIONS OF EXECUTION


bits & pieces on the Deed

NEW DELHI (Reuters) - Thousands of Indians, most of them Muslims, took to the

streets in sporadic protests across the country against the execution of Saddam

Hussein on Saturday, accusing U.S. President George W. Bush of murdering him.

The protests came as New Delhi, which had friendly relations with Saddam's Iraq,

said it was disappointed he was executed and hoped this would not hurt the

process of reconciliation and restoration of peace in that country....



VOICE OF AMERICA - Meanwhile, protests against Saddam's execution have broken

out in several countries around the world - including Iraq, Pakistan and India.

An Iraqi flashes the victory-sign as he rides through the Shiite-majority

Baghdad suburb Sadr City during celebrations of ousted dictator Saddam Hussein's

execution
An Iraqi flashes the victory-sign as he rides through the Shi'ite-majority

Baghdad suburb Sadr City during celebrations of ousted dictator Saddam Hussein's

execution
Street celebrations, however, were reported in Baghdad's Shi'ite Sadr City slum

and other predominantly Shi'ite areas.

Kuwait hailed the execution as fair and just. Iran called it a "victory for the

Iraqi people."

The Hamas-led Palestinian government denounced Saddam's hanging, and Libya

declared three days of official mourning.

Finally, London-based Amnesty International called the trial "flawed," and said

the execution only aggravates the cruel and degrading nature of the death

penalty.


THE GUARDIAN - For the outside world, the most powerful image of Saddam's last

day on earth was the official footage of him being led to the gallows, where a

masked guard placed a rope around his neck - images that within hours had

reached millions on the Internet and fanned protests from overseas politicians

and human rights activists.

Yet for most Iraqis, the more compelling image was a grainier, shakier one

apparently taken by a mobile phone. Broadcast on local television, it showed a

white-shrouded body, neck twisted to one side.

NY TIMES - December 31, 2006 (The semi-mythic "Arab Street")
For Arab Critics, Hussein’s Execution Symbolizes the Victory of Vengeance Over

Justice
By HASSAN M. FATTAH

BEIRUT, Lebanon, Dec. 30 — As daylight broke over the Arab world and news of

Saddam Hussein’s hanging spread over the airwaves and the Internet, the

execution proved just as profound for what it did not change as for what it did.

Hezbollah’s supporters in Beirut woke up on Saturday morning ready for another

day of protests aimed at bringing down the United States-backed government of

Fouad Siniora. Even in Iran, where the Foreign Ministry called the execution a

“jubilation for the thousands who lost family members in the Iran-Iraq war of

the 1980s, officials pledged to continue pursuing their nuclear ambitions and

denounced the United Nations Security Council’s efforts to curb them, Iran’s

official news agency, IRNA, reported.

Throughout the Arab world, opposition movements are still on the run, many pro-

democracy activists are either imprisoned or have simply given up, and the very

targets of the American campaign to transform the Middle East, like Hezbollah,

Iran and Syria, are more emboldened than ever.

Almost four years after United States troops entered Iraq with a broader foreign

policy goal of ushering in a “new Middle East, one built on democracy and rule

of law, the execution of Mr. Hussein on one of the holiest days in Islam marked

the unceremonious demise of that strategy, many Arab analysts said.

“If you compare the results to the objectives the U.S. claimed to realize,

whether it was democracy or control of the region, their policies have evidently

failed, said Nawaf Kabbara, professor of political science at Balamand

University in Beirut. “They were not able to spread democracy, control anything

or make any serious breakthrough. It is a failure on all levels.

For those Arabs who celebrated America’s embrace of the rule of law, the quick

execution, coming before the conclusion of other trials against Mr. Hussein for

crimes against humanity, left a bitter taste of stolen justice. Even Mr.

Hussein’s staunchest enemies expressed a sense of bitterness at the end.

“It is evident that they were not after justice, said Hilal Khashan, a

political science professor at the American University of Beirut. “It was a

political decision, because as soon as they got a sentence on him they executed

him. What mattered was his death rather than finding justice.

For those distrustful or disdainful of American intentions, the notion that the

execution fell on Id al-Adha, one of the most sacred holidays of the year,

seemed to symbolize the triumph of vengeance over justice.

“It looks like they just wanted to take revenge in a vulgar way; that was their

gift to the Shia for the feast, said Khalid al-Dakhil, assistant professor of

political sociology at King Saud University in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia, referring

to Shiites, who were oppressed under Mr. Hussein and now control Iraq.

“Bush and al-Maliki thought they could benefit from this, but this is going to

backfire, he added, referring to President Bush and Prime Minister Nuri Kamal

al-Maliki of Iraq. “Saddam’s execution is going to feed sectarianism and

contribute to more bloodshed.

Id al-Adha, the feast of the sacrifice, is ultimately a commemoration of the

Prophet Abraham’s willingness to sacrifice his son Ishmael for God; instead he

slaughtered a goat, and Muslims today slaughter goats, sheep and even camels to

re-enact the event. As the blood of slaughtered sheep stained the streets of

many Arab cities on Saturday, however, many found it hard to ignore the analogy

of Mr. Hussein himself as a sacrificial lamb.

“Executing the martyr Saddam Hussein on the first day of Adha in one of the

holiest months of the year is meant to defy the feeling of Muslims, to invoke

sectarian strife and to confirm that Bush’s policy as vindictive and aggressive,

said a statement by the union of the Islamist-dominated professional

associations union in Amman, Jordan.

“The phony slogans about freedom and democracy are fake, the statement

continued. “The professional associations mourn the death of the hero, the

martyr Saddam Hussein, and stress that the day of liberating Iraq is near.

Even those who believed Mr. Hussein was guilty expressed doubts about his trial,

and about whether Iraq’s rebuilt justice system was really the kind of civil

institution that could support a true democracy.

“Saddam Hussein was guilty a thousand times over, but still the Americans and

the Iraqi government managed to run a shabby trial, said Jihad al-Khazen, a

columnist and former editor of the pan-Arab newspapers Al Hayat and Asharq al

Awsat. “If they organized a fair trial with international observers that could

have served as a model for other countries. Instead they messed it up, and I

think Saddam in the eyes of many people will now be seen as another martyr.

Many in the region seemed to view the execution as a harbinger of further

sectarian conflict. This was the first time in modern history that a Sunni

dictator had been executed by a Shiite, some analysts noted, a symbolic step

that was widely expected to incur Sunni retribution throughout the region.

American embassies throughout the region warned citizens on Saturday to avoid

protests and be prepared for unrest.

Reporting was contributed by Rasheed Abou al-Samh from Jidda, Saudi Arabia; Suha

Maayeh from Amman, Jordan; Mona el-Naggar from Cairo; and Nada Bakri from

Beirut.

The whole thing disgusts me. But, for now, I'll give Newsweek's astute Fareed

Zakaria, familiar to our TV viewers, the last words:

Zakaria: America’s Mistakes on Saddam’s Trial
By Fareed Zakaria
Newsweek

Jan. 8, 2007 issue - The saga of Saddam's end—his capture, trial and execution—

is a sad metaphor for America's occupation of Iraq. What might have gone right

went so wrong. It is worth remembering that Saddam Hussein was not your run-of-

the-mill dictator. He created one of the most brutal, corrupt and violent

regimes in modern history, something akin to Stalin's Soviet Union, Mao's China

or Kim Jong Il's North Korea. Whatever the strategic wisdom for the United

States, deposing him began as something unquestionably good for Iraq.

But soon the Bush administration dismissed the idea of trying Saddam under

international law, or in a court with any broader legitimacy. This is the

administration, after all, that could see little advantage to a United Nations

mandate for its own invasion and occupation. It put Saddam's fate in the hands

of the new Iraqi government, dominated by Shiite and Kurdish politicians who had

been victims of his reign. As a result, Saddam's trial, which should have been

the judgment of civilized society against a tyrant, is now seen by Iraq's Sunnis

and much of the Arab world as a farce, reflecting only the victors' vengeance.

This was not inevitable. Most Iraqis were happy to see Saddam out of power. In

the months after the American invasion, support for the Coalition Provisional

Authority topped 70 percent. This was so even among Iraq's Sunni Arabs. In the

first months of the insurgency, only 14 percent of them approved of attacks on

U.S. troops. (That number today is 70 percent.) The rebellious area in those

early months was not (Sunni) Fallujah but (Shiite) Najaf.

But during those crucial first months, Washington disbanded the Iraqi Army,

fired 50,000 bureaucrats and shut down the government-owned enterprises that

employed most Iraqis. In effect, the United States dismantled the Iraqi state,

leaving a deep security vacuum, administrative chaos and soaring unemployment.

That state was dominated by Iraq's Sunni elites, who read this not as just a

regime change but a revolution in which they had become the new underclass. For

them, the new Iraq looked like a new dictatorship.

Why Washington made such profound moves with such little forethought remains one

of the many puzzles of the Bush administration's foreign policy. Some of the

decision making was motivated by ideology: Baathism equaled fascism, so every

school teacher who joined the Baath Party to get a job was seen as a closet

Nazi; state-owned enterprises were bad, the new Iraq needed a flat tax, etc.

Some of it was influenced by Shiite exiles who wanted to take total control of

the new Iraq. Some of it simply reflected the bizarre combination of ignorance

and naivete that has marked the policies of Bush's "tough guys."

The administration has never fully understood the sectarian nature of its

policies, which were less "nation building" than they were "nation busting" in

their effects. It kept insisting that it was building a national army and police

force when it was blatantly obvious (even to columnists) that the forces were

overwhelmingly Shiite and Kurdish, mostly drawn from militias with stronger

loyalties to political parties than to the state. The answer to these

fundamentally political objections was technocratic: more training. But a

stronger Shiite Army made—makes—the Sunni populace more insecure and willing to

support the insurgency.

Iraq's Sunnis are not the good guys in this story. They have mostly behaved like

self-defeating thugs. The minority of Sunnis who support Al Qaeda have been

truly barbarous. The point, however, is not their vices but our stupidity. We

summarily deposed not just Saddam Hussein but a centuries-old ruling elite and

then were stunned that they reacted poorly. In contrast, on coming into power in

South Africa, Nelson Mandela did not fire a single white bureaucrat or soldier—

and not because he thought that they had been kind to his people. He correctly

saw the strategy as the way to prevent an Afrikaner rebellion.

It has now become fashionable among Washington neoconservatives to blame the

Iraqis for everything that has happened to their country. "We have given the

Iraqis a republic and they do not appear able to keep it," laments Charles

Krauthammer. Others invoke anthropologists to explain the terrible dysfunctions

of Iraqi culture. There may be some truth to all these claims—Iraq is a tough

place—but the Bush administration is not quite so blameless. It thoughtlessly

engineered a political and social revolution as intense as the French or Iranian

one and then seemed surprised that Iraq could not digest it happily, peaceably

and quickly. We did not give them a republic. We gave them a civil war.

URL: http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/16409404/site/newsweek/


EXECUTION FOR PUBLIC PRURIENT AMUSEMENT
COMPLETE ILLICIT FILM

He was a tyrant, but THIS is lynch-mob 'justice'. Out now.